|Year of Graduation:||2005|
|Year of Induction:||2016|
Henninger was a four-year standout for the men's basketball program from 2001-05 and scored 1,424 points in 95 career games, ranking fourth in career scoring. He also ranks seventh in career field goal percentage (.486), third in career three-point field goals (154), first in career three-point percentage (.439), third in career rebounds (604), fourth in career assists (244) and first in blocked shots (127). As a junior he tossed in a program-record 44 points against Salisbury, a mark that stood until 2015.